KRATOCHVÍL, Jiří, Lukáš PLCH and Eva KORIŤÁKOVÁ. Compliance with ethical rules for scientific publishing in biomedical Open Access journals indexed in Journal Citation Reports. Vnitřní lékařství. Brno: Facta Medica, vol. 65, No 5, p. 338-347. ISSN 0042-773X. 2019.
Other formats:   BibTeX LaTeX RIS
Basic information
Original name Compliance with ethical rules for scientific publishing in biomedical Open Access journals indexed in Journal Citation Reports
Name in Czech Dodržování etických pravidel pro vědecké publikování v biomedicínských časopisech Open Access, které jsou indexovány v Journal Citation Reports
Authors KRATOCHVÍL, Jiří (203 Czech Republic, guarantor, belonging to the institution), Lukáš PLCH (203 Czech Republic, belonging to the institution) and Eva KORIŤÁKOVÁ (203 Czech Republic, belonging to the institution).
Edition Vnitřní lékařství, Brno, Facta Medica, 2019, 0042-773X.
Other information
Original language English
Type of outcome Article in a journal
Country of publisher Czech Republic
Confidentiality degree is not subject to a state or trade secret
WWW URL
RIV identification code RIV/00216224:14110/19:00109581
Organization Lékařská fakulta – Repository – Repository
Keywords (in Czech) biomedicínské časopisy;etická pravidla vědeckého vydávání;Journal Citation Reports;otevřený přístup;predátorské časopisy;Web of Science
Keywords in English biomedical journals;ethical rules of scientific publishing;Journal Citation Reports;open access;predatory journals;Web of Science
Changed by Changed by: RNDr. Daniel Jakubík, učo 139797. Changed: 8/9/2020 03:37.
Abstract
This study examined compliance with the criteria of transparency and best practice in scholarly publishing defined by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA and WAME in Biomedical Open Access journals indexed in Journal Citation Reports (JCR). 259 Open Access journals were drawn from the JCR database and on the basis of their websites their compliance with 14 criteria for transparency and best practice in scholarly publishing was verified. Journals received penalty points for each unfulfilled criterion when they failed to comply with the criteria defined by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA and WAME. The average number of obtained penalty points was 6, where 149 (57.5%) journals received 6 points or less and 110 (42.5%) journals 7 or more points. Only 4 journals met all criteria and did not receive any penalty points. Most of the journals did not comply with the criteria declaration of Creative Commons license (164 journals), affiliation of editorial board members (116), unambiguity of article processing charges (115), anti-plagiarism policy (113) and the number of editorial board members from developing countries (99). The research shows that JCR cannot be used as a whitelist of journals that comply with the criteria of transparency and best practice in scholarly publishing.
Abstract (in Czech)
Studie zjišťovala dodržování kritérií transparentnosti a dobré praxe ve vědeckém publikování definovaných COPE, DOAJ, OASPAt a WAME v biomedicínských Open Access časopisech indexovaných v Journal Citation Reports (JCR). Z JCR bylo excerpováno 259 Open Access časopisů a na jejich webech ručně ověřeno plnění 14 kritérií transparentnosti a dobré praxe ve vědeckém publikování. Časopisy obdržely penalizační body za každé nedodržení kritéria definovaného COPE, DOAJ, OASPA a WAME. Průměrný počet přidělených penalizačních bodů byl 6, přičemž 149 (57,5 %) časopisů získalo 6 a méně bodů a 110 (42,5 %) časopisů získalo 7 a více bodů. Pouze 4 periodika splnila všechna kritéria a nezískala žádný penalizační bod. Nejvíce časopisů nedodrželo kritéria deklarace Creative Commons (164 časopisů), afiliace členů redakční rady (116), jednoznačnosti autorských poplatků (115), antiplagiátorské politiky (113) a počtu členů redakční rady z rozvojových zemí (99). Výzkum ukazuje, že JCR nelze používat jako whitelist časopisů dodržujících kritéria transparentnosti a dobré praxe ve vědeckém publikování.
Type Name Uploaded/Created by Uploaded/Created Rights
Appendix_A_without_authors.xlsx   File version 3/5/2019

Properties

Name
Appendix_A_without_authors.xlsx
Address within IS
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/654822/
Address for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/654822/
Address within Manager
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/654822/?info
Address within Manager for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/654822/?info
Uploaded/Created
Fri 3/5/2019 00:58

Rights

Right to read
  • anyone on the Internet
Right to upload
 
Right to administer:
  • a concrete person Mgr. Lucie Vařechová, uco 106253
  • a concrete person RNDr. Daniel Jakubík, uco 139797
  • a concrete person Mgr. Jolana Surýnková, uco 220973
Attributes
 
Appendix_A_without_authors.xlsx   File version 15/8/2020

Properties

Name
Appendix_A_without_authors.xlsx
Address within IS
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/871678/
Address for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/871678/
Address within Manager
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/871678/?info
Address within Manager for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/871678/?info
Uploaded/Created
Sat 15/8/2020 04:25

Rights

Right to read
  • anyone on the Internet
Right to upload
 
Right to administer:
  • a concrete person Mgr. Lucie Vařechová, uco 106253
  • a concrete person RNDr. Daniel Jakubík, uco 139797
  • a concrete person Mgr. Jolana Surýnková, uco 220973
Attributes
 
Appendix_B_without_authors.xlsx   File version 3/5/2019

Properties

Name
Appendix_B_without_authors.xlsx
Address within IS
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/654823/
Address for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/654823/
Address within Manager
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/654823/?info
Address within Manager for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/654823/?info
Uploaded/Created
Fri 3/5/2019 00:58

Rights

Right to read
  • anyone on the Internet
Right to upload
 
Right to administer:
  • a concrete person Mgr. Lucie Vařechová, uco 106253
  • a concrete person RNDr. Daniel Jakubík, uco 139797
  • a concrete person Mgr. Jolana Surýnková, uco 220973
Attributes
 
Appendix_B_without_authors.xlsx   File version 15/8/2020

Properties

Name
Appendix_B_without_authors.xlsx
Address within IS
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/871677/
Address for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/871677/
Address within Manager
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/871677/?info
Address within Manager for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/871677/?info
Uploaded/Created
Sat 15/8/2020 04:25

Rights

Right to read
  • anyone on the Internet
Right to upload
 
Right to administer:
  • a concrete person Mgr. Lucie Vařechová, uco 106253
  • a concrete person RNDr. Daniel Jakubík, uco 139797
  • a concrete person Mgr. Jolana Surýnková, uco 220973
Attributes
 
clanek.pdf   File version 23/5/2019

Properties

Name
clanek.pdf
Address within IS
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/661977/
Address for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/661977/
Address within Manager
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/661977/?info
Address within Manager for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/661977/?info
Uploaded/Created
Thu 23/5/2019 00:58

Rights

Right to read
  • anyone on the Internet
Right to upload
 
Right to administer:
  • a concrete person Mgr. Lucie Vařechová, uco 106253
  • a concrete person RNDr. Daniel Jakubík, uco 139797
  • a concrete person Mgr. Jolana Surýnková, uco 220973
Attributes
 
clanek.pdf   File version 15/8/2020

Properties

Name
clanek.pdf
Address within IS
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/871676/
Address for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/871676/
Address within Manager
https://repozitar.cz/auth/repo/34891/871676/?info
Address within Manager for the users outside IS
https://repozitar.cz/repo/34891/871676/?info
Uploaded/Created
Sat 15/8/2020 04:25

Rights

Right to read
  • anyone on the Internet
Right to upload
 
Right to administer:
  • a concrete person Mgr. Lucie Vařechová, uco 106253
  • a concrete person RNDr. Daniel Jakubík, uco 139797
  • a concrete person Mgr. Jolana Surýnková, uco 220973
Attributes
 
Print
Add to clipboard Displayed: 29/3/2024 08:06